For Quality, Essential, Generic Medicines
Chapter 3: Rationality of Drugs    
<<Back  
Next>>
     

(vi) Mucoviscidosis is an uncommon condition in India.

(vii) These are unnecessary and costly preparations. Essential drug list of WHO (1992) has not mentioned any of these preparations.

Recommendations: All these formulations of oral digestive enzymes should be banned immediately with the following exception: only enteric coated preparations of pancreatic enzymes may be allowed for restricted use in properly diagnosed cases of pancreatis and mucoviscidosis under expert supervision.

6) Local Antiseptics

Various Preparations of Povidone Iodine, i.e., solutions, mouth washes, scrubs, skin ointments/creams, vaginal pessaries, etc.

Brand Name Examples: Alphadine (Nicholas) mouth wash solution, vaginal pessaries, ointment; Betadine (Win-Medicare) mouth wash solution, pessaries, ointment, scrub; Wokadine (Wockhardt) solution, pessaries, ointment, powder, gargle, scrub; Piodin (Croydon) solution, cream, mouth wash; Povidax (Unique) solution, mouth wash; Torvidone (Torrent) solution, cream; and several such others.

Comments: (i) Povidone-iodine is an iodophore, a loose complex of iodine with poly-vinyl-pyrrolidone. A 10 percent solution is a stable one and when diluted 10 to 100 times with water, it sets iodine in free form which is effective as a germicidal. After such dilution, activity of povidone-iodine increases 10 fold (which is still only 1/15th of the activity of 2 percent tincture of iodine.) [Goodman-Gillman, 1985, 7th edition].

(ii) Considering the above facts:

* formulations like vaginal pessaries and ointments will be useless.
*

solutions, scrubs, etc., should be appropriately diluted. However, the instruction on bottles say "use full strength" or do not advise about dilution. This leads to collossal wastage of anti-septic solution without the desirable anti-septic effect.

Recommendations: (i) Ban preparations like creams, ointments, pessaries. (ii) Allow the formulations like scrubs and solutions in appropriate strength, that is, 10 percent, with clear cut instructions on its use, that is dilute with water by 10 to 100 times before use.

In addition to the above, the following categories of drugs also need to be banned/rationalised:

7) FDCs of Antiasthmatic Drugs

8) FDCs of Antacids

9) Lactobacillus Preparations

10) Topical Anticoagulants

11) Oral/Injectable Haemostatics except Vitamin K

12) Cerebral Activators such as Pyritinol and Piractecam (Torrent)

13) Cerebral Vasodilators

14) Placentrex (Albert David) and products based on human/animal placenta

15) Ginseng and other such so-called sexual rejuvenators

16) Presence of Alcohol not required as solvents

17) Entire categories of products under the so-called label of Nutritional Supplements.

18) Drugs (of non-modern medical systems) approved by the FDA purporting to cure snake bites, increase semen, increase the risk of abortion, increase fertility, etc.

Source: Additional Affidavit of LOCOST in Supreme Court Writ Petition No.698/93, Drug Action Forum and ors versus UOI and ors
More experssion doesn't necessariy mean better !

     
<<Back
Top
Next>>